skip to main |
skip to sidebar
I am not special. I am unique.
My Sunday move was the new opera Lincoln in the Bardo streamed from the Metropolitan Opera. Alas, by the time I post this it will be available only to Met subscribers.
The story is from a novel of the same name by George Saunders. The book won the Booker Prize in 2017. The librettist is Royce Vavrek and the composer is Missy Mazzoli.
The setting is the Bardo. I think it is a Buddhist idea. It is a place one goes after life until one admits they are dead. Those in the Bardo think they are merely ill and will recover soon and return to life. Since many died violently they walk around with blood on their clothing or faces.
President Abraham Lincoln is there, not because of his own death, but because his son Willie died in 1862. Willie can’t move on yet because his father still comes to the crypt to grieve (in history Willie’s remains are eventually moved from Washington to the same cemetery where is father is buried in Springfield, Illinois).
We meet a few of the characters and learn how they came to the Bardo. Vollman was struck by a beam as he was about to make love to his wife for the first time and must contend with a gigantic penis (which I doubt had been seen on the Met stage before, or mentioned in my blog). Bevins committed suicide because he was gay (in 1862). Miss Traynor, sung by a countertenor, died from a fever before experiencing much of life. We aren’t told right away why the Reverend, a man played by a soprano, was there. Other people are Havens and Mrs. Hodge who had been slaves. They figure out who Lincoln is and want to use his visits to Willie’s crypt as a chance for them to influence his opinion on slavery. And, of course, Willie, played quite well by a boy soprano, and Lincoln. Each one of them gets moments to shine. There is also a big chorus.
Vollman, Bevins, Reverend, and Willie are at one point surrounded by multiple copies of a person they loved (Bevins by his male lover) who urges their beloved to follow them. Since the residents believe they are still alive and don’t know where they would be taken to they refuse.
There are also a lot of puppets, including tentacles that try to wrap around a person and forever hold them into the Bardo.
It’s a most unusual opera. I quite enjoyed it.
The countertenor mentioned above is Anthony Roth Costanzo. By happy coincidence he was the guest on NPR’s Fresh Air today to explain and demonstrate that a countertenor is one who sings in the falsetto range, which is the range of a woman. The countertenor thankfully replaced the castrati, who had the operation preventing their voice from dropping. Costanzo said that in the 1700s the operation to produce a castrato was banned by the church – but if the operation had been done the church would gladly hire them to sing the high parts the church refused to hire women to sing.
Meg Anderson of NPR reported on a visit by a group of Americans involved in criminal justice in New York to the Tegel Prison in Berlin, Germany. The reason for the visit was to learn about the more humane prisons in Germany and Norway.
Prison cells in Germany are required to have natural light and ventilation – the windows open though there are bars over them. The furniture is made of wood and not bolted to the floor or walls. The toilet has a privacy screen. The place does not smell of too many bodies in stagnant air. The prisoners wear street clothes instead of prison uniforms. Those prisoners still long for better food.
After the Holocaust, Germany adopted a new constitution that centers on protecting human dignity, including in its prisons. In Germany, the loss of freedom is seen as the punishment, not the conditions inside.
...
By law, life inside a German prison has to resemble life outside prison as much as possible, a concept known as normalization.
...
There are daily schedules that include discussion groups and activities aimed at "learning conflict resolution and being able to practice it, learning to care for each other and be vulnerable and practice that, so that you can care and be vulnerable when you go home," Shanahan says.
That matters. Almost everyone who goes to prison in the U.S. is eventually released.
Both prisoners and guards benefit. The guards because prisoners are much less violent. The prisoners because they are less likely to commit new crimes after release. They are given useful work, such as landscaping, which makes them feel calmer and more relaxed. They know they are headed towards release.
Yes, some prison systems in the US are beginning to try these ideas.
My last update on Russia’s war attempt to annex Ukraine was quite a while ago. It’s been one long slog over 4¾ years. Right now Russia seems to be enduring more damage. One of my posts in October of 2022 was about an attack on the Kerch Bridge, the Russian structure built to connect the Russian mainland to the annexed Crimea.
And now it has been struck again, this time with more consequential damage. IronTortoise of the Daily Kos community has some details, including that the damage was done by Ukraine’s Flamingo missiles and that it dropped a stretch of the road bridge into the Kerch Strait, blocking all ship traffic between the Sea of Azov and the Black Sea.
In an update IronTortoise quoted an article on MSN. The timing was deliberate to happen just before Putin is to meet with Xi Jinping of China and the nasty guy. This would demonstrate how weak Putin really is. The whole thing was carried out with drones providing guidance to the missiles and did not use Starlink and Starshield, the communications network controlled by Eon Musk which he recently prevented Ukraine’s use for a while.
A second report by annieli of the Kos community has a lot of photos and videos of the damage. Some even show damage to the rail side of the bridge. That will be much more easily repaired, but still halts train traffic for a while.
There is also a description of Russia’s response of taking out bridges in Kyiv.
IronTortoise also posted a collection of memes about the collapsed bridge, such as:
A LEGO Kerch Bridge set requiring “disassembly.”
The Kerch Bridge pronouns are “was/were.”
The Sea of Azov is now Lake Zelenskyy (if the nasty guy can rename things...)
The nasty guy: “You don’t have the cards!”
Zelenskyy: “How about a game of bridge.”
Douglas Schonenberg of the Kos community discussed the prevalent practice of parents telling their children that they are special. The problem is that “special” implies superiority. And we’ve seen over the last decade (though through human history) the need to claim superiority means violent oppression of others, starting with racism. Schonenberg discusses this at length.
Most of what a child is told to feel special about is an accident of birth, such as being white, male, Christian, and straight. Claiming superiority for traits the child has no control over doesn’t make sense.
Schonenberg says instead we should teach our children that they are unique. They have a combination of characteristics, talents, perspectives, experiences, and weaknesses that no one else has. That’s great and society has a place for that combination.
But that unique combination does not make you better than someone else, more deserving of respect. It does not give you the right to oppress others. You can be proud of who you are without needing to believe you are better than others.
Now, I’m not saying we shouldn’t encourage our children. I’m not saying we shouldn’t tell them we love them, celebrate their accomplishments, or help them feel good about themselves.
Of course we should.
But there’s a difference between telling a child that they are loved and telling them that they are better than someone else. There’s a difference between teaching a child to believe in themselves and teaching them that they deserve more than other people. And I think we have lost sight of that difference.
In the comments various writers insist that “special” and “unique” mean the same thing. Schonenberg insists they are different, even quoting definitions:
The definition of special is Better, greater, or more important than usual.
The definition of unique is Existing as the sole example with nothing else exactly like it.
There is a difference. I am unique. There is nobody exactly like me. I am not special. I am not better than anyone else.
And repeating his basic point:
I don't want children growing up thinking less of themselves. I want them growing up without thinking less of other people.
That is the distinction I am making, and it's the entire point of my musing.
Jon Paul Syndor of the Street Prophets group in the Kos community discussed Biblical interpretation. That interpretation never ends and evolves as our understanding of human nature and the Kingdom of God evolves.
But humans want certainty. We want total understanding so we can have total control of our lives, so we can have stability and order. But that diminishes our understanding of the text and of life. It means our future conforms to our past and not get better.
Complications in Biblical understanding help us see what we were previously blind to. When an interpretation claims authority we must be suspicious. The Bible forbids using it to approve one’s preexisting opinions, of saying “I feel strongly about this, so God must agree with me.” But those supposedly “Biblical” prejudices work against the generosity and inclusiveness of Jesus. The person wants to preserve things, including their superiority, rather than create the expansive and inclusive society that Jesus teaches. The Bible is not for gaining power over others.
In Monday’s pundit roundup for Kos Greg Dworkin quote Ethan Chen of DeCalibrate discussing why the South, the Bible Belt, had turned blue. Many had thought the region was too racist for such a swing. One component was a much higher black turnout. But that’s not the whole explanation either.
Thus, the other factor in the Bible Belt Tsunami was an extraordinary shift among the region’s white voters.
Alas, the quote doesn’t go into more detail.
Paul Krugman, writing for his own Substack, discussed voodoo economics, a term made popular in the Reagan era.
While Trump has chosen to betray the conventional Republican view by imposing tariffs, which are effectively a tax on Americans, he has been a staunch practitioner of the standard Republican voodoo, insisting that lower taxes on the rich will supercharge the economy. And we can be sure that when a future Democratic president tries to raise taxes in order to lower the federal deficit that has become unsustainable due to Republican tax cuts, that the Republicans will cry “job destroyer,” as they did with both Bill Clinton and Barack Obama.
The quote says that behind the paywall he’ll discuss the Reaganomics legend, the long-term harmful consequences of Republican tax-cut zombie, and what Democrats can do.
Matt Grossmann tweeted a chart of the political ads that focused on cultural issues rather than economic issues in the 2022, 2024, and 2026 elections. In 2022 House Democratic candidates and Senate Republicans both talked about cultural issues about 32% of the time. In 2024 House Democrats featured cultural issues about 47% of the time with the rest of the candidates for Congress discussing them between 33% and 37% of the time. In 2026 Senate Republicans talked cultural issues about 53% of the time while others talked about them 10% to 21% of the time.
David Shuster of Blue Amp Media discussing the new Democrats on Capitol Hill for orientation.
The new arrivals looked cheerful, purposeful, positively delighted to be there.
What a wonderful sight.
After years of watching the Republican Party turn Congress into a combination of sleazy traveling circus, Ayn Rand debating society, and badly managed lunatic asylum, the appearance of these new Democrats was like opening the curtains in a room that has been occupied too long by unwashed meth addicts.
You could practically hear the furniture sigh with relief.
Sarah Longwell of The Bulwark wrote Republicans didn’t have much of a record to run on.
So instead, Republicans spent a huge amount of time and money trying to gin up hysteria about trans people doing horrifying things like using the bathroom, or about brown-skinned students enjoying a football game, or about Muslims.
It didn’t work—at least, not this year. Partly because it’s a little hard to sell voters on putting the same people back in charge when everything’s going down the drain. But also because the number of voters energized about supposedly threatening minorities just wasn’t sufficient to withstand the blue wave.
But there were some voters with whom all the fearmongering about Muslims specifically really sank in. Some of this has already popped up in focus groups this year about Abdul El-Sayed and even Vivek Ramaswamy. Zohran Mamdani is occasionally also in the mix, natch. Islamophobia is now a major part of the Republican Triangle of Doom—the voters have heard it from the politicians (like Greg Abbott) and right-wing media figures, so now they’re going to demand to hear more and more of it. It’s going to make it incredibly difficult for the GOP to rebuild: They can either play into the bigotry and alienate people who would rather hear about things like the cost of living, or they can abandon the bigotry and thereby ignore one of their base’s growing concerns.
Yesterday was the 19th anniversary of my first post to this blog. This post is number 5,706. Over the last seven days I’ve been getting about 15 thousand views a day. From the time that Blogger started keeping records for me back in 2010 there have been 2,758,862 views and most of those have been in the last two years.
I’m still interested in sharing news and opinions so I plan to keep going for quite a while.
No comments:
Post a Comment