skip to main |
skip to sidebar
The Republicans break it, Democrats fix it cycle
Pete Buttigieg, who should know better, said Biden and Democrats “really overtorqued on the student loan thing.” He explained:
As a party, I have a very hard time explaining to my relatives in Michigan who did not go to college why they should be paying for people who do. … I don’t believe in like a magic wand to fix that for everybody who borrowed money.
Thom Hartmann of the Daily Kos community explains this is looking at the issue from the wrong end.
Student debt essentially didn’t exist in America before Reagan. It was created intentionally and we can intentionally end it.
Before Reagan states paid for 65% of the cost, federal aid covered 15%, and the remaining 20% could be paid through part time jobs.
Before Reagan was president he was governor of California. His concern was the peasants would become too well-educated and prosperous. Yes, this is the old Republican belief that there must be a strong social hierarchy and if you aren’t born into the top you had no business trying to reach that high. Even a solid middle class with its voting power was a threat. And college boosted the chance of reaching the middle class.
So Reagan’s Director of the Office of Management and Budget, David Stockman, told a reporter in 1981:
I don’t accept the notion that the federal government has an obligation to fund generous grants to anybody that wants to go to college.
That started the student debt crisis. Students became part of the “tax-eaters” – people who received benefits from the government. Other tax-eaters were those on welfare, Medicaid, and Medicare. They were seen as a drag on the economy and not an obligation of the taxpayer.
Since then Republicans have argued paying of student loans would be a “perfect opportunity” for young people to “learn fiscal responsibility, a lesson they’ll need as adults.” The quotes are from an unnamed Michigan senator in 2005.
But it’s all nonsense. The GI Bill after WWII proved it. And its effects have been much studied, such as the book, Over Here: How the GI Bill Transformed the American Dream, by Edward Humes. Hartmann quoted a summary by by Mary Paulsell for the Columbia Daily Tribune:
[That] groundbreaking legislation gave our nation 14 Nobel Prize winners, three Supreme Court justices, three presidents, 12 senators, 24 Pulitzer Prize winners, 238,000 teachers, 91,000 scientists, 67,000 doctors, 450,000 engineers, 240,000 accountants, 17,000 journalists, 22,000 dentists and millions of lawyers, nurses, artists, actors, writers, pilots and entrepreneurs.
In 1952 dollars the GI Bill education benefit cost $7 billion. The economic benefit traced to that cost was $35.6 billion over 40 years. The government received $12.8 billion in taxes because wages were higher.
In addition, that educated workforce made it possible for America to lead the world in innovation, R&D, and new business development for three generations. We invented the transistor, the integrated circuit, the internet, new generations of miracle drugs, sent men to the moon and reshaped science.
The nation investing in educating its citizen wasn’t new with Franklin Roosevelt. Lincoln signed the Morrill Act in 1862, giving states land to sell or use for public colleges. It is also basic in other developed countries – student debt there doesn’t exist or is rare.
Who benefits from student debt? Banks. It’s another way to suck money from the poor to the rich.
And who is harmed? Lost scientific leadership and three generations of young people are prevented from starting businesses, having families, and buying homes.
The pandemic Paycheck Protection Program showed Republican members of Congress are not opposed to “tax-eaters” – as long as it is themselves. They each pocketed forgiven PPP loans ranging from $38,000 to $4.3 million.
Another reason why Buttigieg’s comment at the top is strange is because during his 2020 campaign he and his husband Chasten listed carrying $131,296 in student loans. Then he said, “I believe in reducing student debt.” So stop parroting conservative talking points.
Want to make America great again? The new Congress should zero out student debt and revive strong government support for college education.
In the comments of last Sunday’s pundit roundup for Kos Greg Dworkin posted the priorities of new senator James Talarico of Texas:
+ We must get Big Money out of our politics so no billionaire – or trillionaire – can buy our elections.
+ We must ban gerrymandering nationwide – in red states and blue states alike.
+ We must unrig this economic system that only benefits the top 1%.
+ We must pass universal healthcare so no one goes bankrupt just because they get sick.
+ We must invest in our teachers and our students and build an American public education system that is the envy of the world.
+ We must overhaul this broken immigration system and build a pathway to citizenship for our neighbors who have been here for years.
+ We must cut red tape and build millions of new homes so every American can realize the dream of homeownership.
+ We must regulate artificial intelligence, crack down on data centers, and pass an AI Dividend so every American has a share in this AI future.
+ We must end these forever wars that are driving up prices and champion a new, values-based foreign policy.
A very good list! About the only thing he missed was instituting strong ethics laws.
Further down in the comments exlrrp posted a meme related to the total airplane grounding ordered by the Federal Aviation Administration last Friday that snarled air passengers for several days.
If our air traffic controls systems were so outdated and in need of dire repairs as Sean Duffy now claims, why have they spent so much money and time on a f*cking ballroom, arch, golf course, and reflecting pool?
In Wednesday’s roundup Dworkin quoted Dr. Eric Lullove of Blue Amp Media talking about the airplane grounding.
I can’t tell you one of the technicians fired Feb. 14, 2025 would have been standing next to that router Nov. 13, 2026. What I can tell you is a modernization program two administrations asked Congress to fund was refused; an agency whose assessment was 3/4 of its systems were failing; a maintenance workforce cut by DOGE without checking if it reduced safety; a $12.5 billion down payment the FAA said was $20 billion short; a GAO report warning the new program had no credible cost or schedule; and a Secretary who, standing in front of the wreckage, asked for $50 billion and blamed his predecessors.
DOGE didn’t cause the router to fail. DOGE is why there was no margin when it did. That’s what this project produced across government: not savings–the removal of people and redundancy that stood between a small failure and a catastrophic one.
In the comments a meme posted by exlrrp:
The reflecting pool and Trump’s buddy who got paid for it want you to know Trump can be totally trusted with 50 billion dollars to fix the FAA.
And another meme posted by exlrrp:
Biden left such a mess of our aviation system that Trump had to immediately destroy the east wing and start building a ballroom.
In today’s roundup Chitown Kev quoted Elie Mystal of The Nation:
Everyone knows the broad contours of how we got here. Republicans run for office on the claim that government cannot work, and then spend their time in power destroying government just to prove that they were right. Neoliberals help Republicans by ceding critical government functions to the private sector, which in turn ignores the public good in an all-consuming chase for greater margins and profits. Occasionally things get so bad that the people elect leaders who are modestly responsible—who fix things just enough that the next guy (and it’s pretty much always a guy) can come in and complain about taxes and Black people and get elected to wreck the government again. […]
Oh, and just in case you think I am merely listing petty inconveniences, the National Security Agency’s internal communication system went down while I was writing this. […]
It’s one thing for stuff to break. Entropy is undefeated, but ens---tification is a choice. Things are breaking because a small cadre of people have decided it’s more profitable for things to break than it is for things to last. We’re not suffering because of the slings and arrows of outrageous fortune. We’re suffering because we are paying for the fortunes of others. My computer is more expensive because AI is buying up all the RAM. My water is more expensive because AI is sucking up all the water. And all the while my e-mail sometimes doesn’t work, probably because of some AI assistant I never even asked for.”
Paul Krugman writing for his own Substack:
Why…have so many pundits and politicians tried to downplay the role of everything except affordability? Why the rush to ICEwash and griftwash the midterms?
Here is my explanation. Many people in the pundit and political class – particularly older members of that class – are in a reflexive cringe mode due to losing twice to Donald Trump. They don’t fully trust that American voters care about issues beyond their own pocketbooks. Thus they fear that acknowledging the sheer evil of MAGA will come across to swing voters as extremist and pandering to their “woke” base.
But however reasonable the strategy of “it’s all about affordability” may appear, I think it is wrong — as the evidence from G. Elliott Morris and David Nir clearly indicates. Affordability is no longer the sole motivator as it was in the 2024 election. Instead, in voters’ minds it is now part of a constellation of failures and outrages perpetrated by MAGA.
Michael Franklin of The Contrarian on the Congressional Republicans that survived the election:
They have not seen the light. They lie nonstop. Joe Biden got well-earned applause for reducing Rudy Giuliani’s vocabulary to “a noun and a verb and 9/11.” This generation of Republicans has its own formula: A noun, a verb, a lie, and a curiously concocted commission on why your tone is the real problem and we’re left wondering what Democrat embarrassed himself enough to provide credibility to an obvious bad-faith effort.
Washington needs a mass unlearning of the idea that proximity to powerful people is an accomplishment, that refusing to name wrongdoing demonstrates maturity, that a Republican’s willingness to speak pleasantly deserves more credit than a Democrat’s willingness to confront the harm that Republican helped inflict. These ineffective ideals are already looking for a back door into the next Congress. We should recognize them before we let the opposition set the terms.
The Republicans who survived this election have not earned a presumption of changed convictions, as the Hegseth impeachment effort clearly showed. Losing colleagues does not erase the bulls--- they co-signed explicitly for the past decade and, in too many cases, implicitly for much longer. Their records still belong to them. Their responsibility survives the election.
In the comments exlrrp posted a meme and a couple of tweets in reply. The meme:
Trump on FAA funding in the Big Beautiful Bill: “We were given $12 billion. I said don’t spend it until we can do the whole system. I made a lot of money building things. I know how to do this stuff. We want to give one big beautiful contract.”
Reply from Michael Kasdan: “Here is Trump admitting that he stopped the FAA from spending the billions of dollars Congress appropriated. Unreal.”
More from Ron Filipkowski:
The problem with Congress appropriating a big chunk of money for an important project like air traffic control or anything else is that this mafia govt will give the job on a no-bid contract to a start-up his kids invested in or someone unqualified who gave Trump’s PAC $1 million.
A comment by Doctor Who:
Elie Mystal got me thinking how we get out of this “Republicans break it, Democrats fix it” cycle. What have we been doing in our “fix it” portion of the cycle that leads voters to elect Republicans to put us back into the “break it” portion of the cycle?
Now that we are on the verge of another Democrats “fix it” portion of the cycle (especially if we take back the Presidency in 2028), what do we need to do differently to avoid a future Republican “break it” period?
I think the answer lies in not just returning the country to where it was before the Republicans broke it, but to make it better, a lot better for the common man/woman. That means going forward with a boldly Progressive agenda. That means significantly increasing taxes on the very rich to pay for programs like M4A and maybe lowering taxes on the poor and lower middle class who are living paycheck to paycheck. Yes, this is the Bernie Sanders : AOC policy agenda.
Why do I think this could break the cycle?
Because it’s been done before. FDR did it. It lead to several decades of Democratic control and more importantly made life better for the middle class.
At least that’s my cycle breaking theory.
The Lone Apple posted a tweet by Paul Arzooman:
The problem with Vance and the people he surrounds himself with is that he thinks everyone is as ideologically loony as MAGA – just a different ideology. He doesn’t get that the voters said, “Your job is to be a good little doggy and give us what we need when we snap our fingers.”
Last Friday Bill in Portland, Maine, in his Cheers and Jeers column for Kos quoted late night commentary. Here’s one:
“President Trump announced that he has asked Vice President J.D. Vance to, quote, ‘focus his complete and total attention on the massive corruption and crime taking place in Democrat-run cities and states throughout the U.S.’ Okay, but that’s gonna be a lot more work now that there are so many of them.”
—Seth Meyers
No comments:
Post a Comment